Waverly and Jeremy talk about a new corpse that also won the trivia night. Rachel reminds Nicole that Doc will forgive her if she explains her reasons. Rachel apologizes for letting Billy out and they talk. Rachel calls her chicken kicker so Nicole reminds her of the promise never to tell anyone. At Shorty’s, Rachel and Nicole talk about her freeing Billy. She confronts the demons about the dead man while Doc assures Wynonna that he will keep an eye out for the demon.
They fight over her shooting someone in the back so she points Peacemaker at him causing him to show his fangs. Now alone at the bar, she confronts him about killing the humans and tries to seduce him but he assures her that his morals are sound. Wynonna arrives at the Glory Hole drunk and interrupts Doc’s socializing but Doc assures them that they are safe. A man in a restaurant is killed by two bite marks. Wynonna cheers when she sees the fang marks on the man’s neck and assumes it was Doc so she rushes off to see him. The dead man won trivia at Shorty’s last week which while tragic, makes Waverly and Jeremy excited. Jeremy shows the Earp’s a murdered corpse in the office since the rats took over the morgue. Jeremy arrives in an apron covered in blood which unnerves the citizens. She disregards the complaints but Waverly warns Wynonna that the town is going under with the few supply runs. At the station, Wynonna avoids the citizen’s minor grievances. He thinks she’s butthurt but she claims it’s because of Rachel, to which Nedley tells her that Rachel let out Billy.
He thinks she was the best sheriff since he was in the office, but she deflects to trivia night but he attempts to bring it back to her. Nicole pours another beer but Nedley stops her so she can help him set up for trivia night. A man finds a dead deputy and panics over being killed by the Earp heir, seconds before he transforms into a werewolf. Waverly suggests that Wynonna become sheriff for a bit since the town is quiet. Nicole leaves as she tells them to see her at trivia while she plans the wedding. Waverly arrives and the women bicker until the Earp’s try to get Nicole back to the Sheriff's spot. Wynonna and Nicole face off as they spar in the Sheriff's department. Wynonna and the others prepare for a night of trivia in Purgatory, but the night is marred by murder, mayhem and brain sandwiches.